Jump to content






The self-teacher

Posted by TofuMan, 09 February 2011 · 832 views

software Rosetta Stone My Japanese Coach
I've always taught myself. Classes usually don't work well with me- either too slow or too focused on simple fact memorization.

My usual learning method:

  • skim read once, deep read the second time
  • get several books on the same subject and read them all
  • some combination of the above

This time I started out pretty much the same way. I grabbed a bunch of training / reference materials and dove in.

Doing a bit of research it seemed like the gold standard in training was Rosetta Stone, so I purchased that and started to work my way through it.

Going into it I had the recommendation that you don't learn using Romaji (phonetic writing of Japanese in the Latin/English alphabet). I also read that it was better to go straight into the Kanji. With that in mind I set the output to Furigana (Kanji with the Hirigana for pronouncing it above), thinking that was the best option. Worked my way through the first unit without too much difficulty. When I got to the unit final test though, I utterly bombed it. :blink:

Each of the individual lessons were pretty easy to successfully pass. I struggled a bit with some of the speaking parts (with long sentences), but that was it. Looking back on it, I realized the lessons were so easy I wasn't picking up enough real understanding of what the program was trying to teach. Multiple choice can be pretty easy, especially when there are pictures involved. "Said something about a fish, must be the fish picture." :huh: The unit final test, unlike the lessons, was an interactive lengthy dialog. Felt like a deer in the headlights. :GGRR:

Best I could figure was that there was just too much to really internalize the core points they were making in the lessons. The long strings of foreign sounds and characters left too many gaps in my comprehension. Trying to associate the sounds with the symbols was really difficult. :wacko: I did pick up a few Kanji (e.g. male 男 female 女), but it was a struggle to really follow along at full speed.

Thinking that repetition from a different angle might help I picked up My Japanese Coach for the Nintendo DS. That seemed to help a bit, but I soon found myself under unfortunate circumstances and had to drop everything for a little over a year...




You should learn hiragana and katakana before you attempt kanji!!! Learning Kanji before learning hiragana and katakana, is like...learning words in the dictionary, without first learning the alphabet! ^^;
Hi -- I've also been exploring Japanese for the past few months. I think it's a good strategy to work with lots of different materials... that way, you see many perspectives, and things will eventually start to make sense. Here's a list of everything I've been working with:

http://japanese-lesson.com/ -- this is where I learned Hiragana and Katakana. They have really good interactive learning aids for this. They also have some Kanji and conversational instruction, but I haven't gotten to those yet.

Pimsleur -- I downloaded this course to my Android phone from audible.com. This is a good introduction to spoken Japanese. If you do at least 30 minutes every day, you will retain what you learn... but it does move a bit slowly.

Japanese Demystified -- a self-teaching textbook that has good reviews. I've only gotten through the first section or two, but it seems pretty good. I started getting confused around the te-forms, so I think I need to go back and really learn the basic conjugations of a bunch of common verbs.

Human Japanese -- This is a nice interactive learning tool, with lessons on language and culture. I downloaded the free demo and worked through it... quite a few of the lessons are included in the demo. I haven't bought the full version, though.

Heisig RTK (pdf download link) -- RTK = "Remembering the Kanji" by James Heisig, aka "The Heisig method". This is a popular way to learn the writing and the meaning of the Kanji. However, you don't learn the Japanese pronunciations here. Heisig's idea is that you should separate out those two learning tasks. It's a bit controversial, but a lot of people swear by it. I've worked through some of it, and it does seem to work pretty well, although some of his mnemonic devices seem a bit convoluted to me. EDIT: this PDF is just the first part of the course (276 Kanji.) For the rest, you'd have to purchase the book. But this will give you a good idea of whether or not it will work for you.

http://kanjidamage.com/ -- another Kanji learning resource which seems pretty popular. This one does include the onyomi and kunyomi (pronunciations.) It's a bit irreverent... not afraid to use R-rated mnemonics. Hey, whatever works!

http://ankisrs.net/ -- "spaced repetition system" for learning with flashcards. There are decks available for the Heisig RTK system, and also probably for other aspects of Japanese. This will help you review and test your knowledge.

Sentence Patterns -- I haven't really gotten into this yet, but it looks really good. Even though I've only spent 5 minutes with this book, it already taught me the key difference between "watashi wa" and "watashi ga".

A good dictionary -- you'll need one!

http://lang-8.com/ -- this is a cool website where you can connect with native speakers of Japanese or any language. You can write posts in the language you're trying to learn, and native speakers of that language will post comments and corrections. And in return, you can make comments and corrections for people who are trying to learn English.

Other good sites for exploration:

http://www.reddit.com/r/LearnJapanese/
http://journeytojapa...y.blogspot.com/
http://www.tofugu.co...ning-resources/
http://www.tofugu.co...anese-for-free/
http://www.guidetoja...g/learn/grammar
http://www.nhk.or.jp/lesson/english/


All that should keep you busy for a while! Good luck!
PS -- I haven't heard good things about Rosetta Stone.

You should learn hiragana and katakana before you attempt kanji!!! Learning Kanji before learning hiragana and katakana, is like...learning words in the dictionary, without first learning the alphabet! ^^;


You're absolutely correct- I knocked out ひらがな and カタカナ before I did anything. ;) Used the White Rabbit Press Kana cards for that.

Hi -- I've also been exploring Japanese for the past few months. I think it's a good strategy to work with lots of different materials... that way, you see many perspectives, and things will eventually start to make sense. Here's a list of everything I've been working with:


Thanks for all the links! I'll run through what you've posted and see how it compliments/improves what I've found on my own. I'll be posting more over the next few days on what I've been finding / exploring. Currently I'm trying to memorize some Kanji and have quite a bit to say about it. :)

Heisig RTK (pdf download link) -- RTK = "Remembering the Kanji" by James Heisig, aka "The Heisig method". This is a popular way to learn the writing and the meaning of the Kanji. However, you don't learn the Japanese pronunciations here. Heisig's idea is that you should separate out those two learning tasks. It's a bit controversial, but a lot of people swear by it. I've worked through some of it, and it does seem to work pretty well, although some of his mnemonic devices seem a bit convoluted to me. EDIT: this PDF is just the first part of the course (276 Kanji.) For the rest, you'd have to purchase the book. But this will give you a good idea of whether or not it will work for you.


i can endorse this statement. It is a great book, I learned how to write(from sheer memory) and recogonize 2000 kanji in the span of two months. And in the fall I got the other book in the series and I now know 3000 plus kanji

April 2024

M T W T F S S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425 26 2728
2930     

Recent Entries

Recent Comments

Categories