|
| |
Oikaze
02-November 11 |
| Koharu is different in style and aura from a lot of them (though somewhat similar to Tsuji), but she definitely proved her value with her solo career: At her peak, she was outselling Morning Musume itself! I'm not aware of any other H!P soloist (not even Gottsuan or Ayaya) who can say that. |
 |
|
|
| |
wildstarr
02-November 11 |
| ^ but you could also say that one of Goto or Aya singles have sold as much as all of Koharu's singles put together. |
|
|
|
| |
Oikaze
02-November 11 |
| ^ Gottsuan is undoubtedly the greatest idol ever, but in fairness to Koharu, the sales of H!P in general had declined dramatically by the time Koharu started her solo career. I wasn't saying she was a better soloist... H!P in general had declined in quality, but I was saying that her accomplishment of outselling Morning Musume, whatever the context, by itself entitles her to a place in the pantheon of Dream Morning Musume. |
|
|
|
| |
cunning
03-November 11 |
| Seconding what Oikaze said, Both Goto and Aya were soloists during the golden era of H!P, which was over before Koharu joined. Its not really fair to compare them. Not saying that Koharu is better than them, but i do believe she deserves her spot in DMM. |
|
|
|
| |
theonlyfiona
03-November 11 |
| Every (future) former Momusu member deserves a spot in Dorimusu. Period. |
|
|
|
Comments (Showing the latest 5 of 6) 
