364 replies to this topic

[Fluffis]

Moe had newcommer in the bag! I am shocked to see Zukki do that well since so many of her fans are hiding in an iglo and have been since June. Happy to see Takagi do well in the vocalist category. I sort of feel bad for not voting for her as best performer, but at least she does not know I exsist so it is ok oh wait she does and now I feel guilty lol

[thegabriel]

Thank you for all your hard work.

 

Let's see how my list did???

 

2.  +10 Suzuki Airi

8.  +9   Fukumura Mizuki

41 +8   Miyazaki Yuka

13 +7   Yajima Maimi

23 +6   Yamaki Risa

10 +5   Ishida Ayumi

3   +4   Oda Sakura

21 +3   Ogata Haruna

1   +2   Sato Masaki

5   +1   Murota Mizuki

 

Best Idol Group - Morning Musume '16- 1

Best Newcomer - Onoda Saori -

Best Singer - Suzuki Airi- 1

Best Dancer - Ishida Ayumi- 2

Best Performer - Murota Mizuki- 3

 

Not bad, not bad at all.

[KawaiiLand]

So much love for Masaki & Musume from H!O   . Kamiko, yes she's well loved too .. but what surprised me is Funakki..  I'm so happy .. 

 

Best singer & dancer are familiar face, we all know that, best performer I hope Murotan get the top position. and pleasee the best newcomer can form a strong new sub-unit 

 

 Where are Juice=Juice fan 

 

A big thanks to the counter team for the hard work. 

 

HAPPY NEW YEAR 2017

[Konohita]

I wasn't able to vote since I'm new but I'm so glad that Maachan got the 1st place thanks for the hard work while counting the votes and post the results in a timely manner, good job!!

[minaeshi]

I wasn't able to vote since I'm new but I'm so glad that Maachan got the 1st place thanks for the hard work while counting the votes and post the results in a timely manner, good job!!

Wow you joined just after voting closed! Please do consider joining us next year! 

[Danes83]

Happy New year everyone. 2016 such an important year for haropro, so many important events occurred.

Here's my notes about the result :
- Masaki was loved by everyone, by overseas fans like us and domestic fans (compared to japan polling)
- Same goes to Sakura, Fukuhime, Maria & Haruka, both have placed as high as japan poll
- MM still the best group for overseas fans
- Harunan (Iikubo) placed high in overseas polling, while not so popular in japan's polling
- C-ute & Momochi members still have big fanbase overseas. Airi, Momochi, Maimi placed among top. And C-ute was the 2nd best group
- Watchout for Angerme, marked as another top group.
- Even Moe & Muro places in top-6 among the popular members.
- Just keep on going for Kobushi Factory, with right direction they may become more famous than 2016.
Kobushi member's also need to boost their popularity more.
- Tsubaki Factory just established, and debut this January.. Hope the progress will be the same as Kobushi
- Country Girls, mmm... Manaka-loss still a nightmare
- J=J need to put some radical change, in music & members. They've been overtake by new members/groups. Maybe add more member will solve this issue

[Sky☆Dancer]

Aww, thanks for all your hard work counting up everything! I kept meaning to submit a list but never got around to it. But it was nice to see the list. I thought I really couldn't pull a list together, but seeing how low some girls were like Hirose Ayaka were, I guess I do have a preference. So next year!

[keaine]

Ok, so now for the second post!

 

Spoiler

First, global remarks. There were 226 voters for the "Best idol" category, and around the same number for the other ones. I think that's great. Compared to the Japanese one, with approximately 3500 voters, I think we can be proud, although, and I can hear some people already, I can't really compare a one week vote with a vote running for more than a month. Anyway, that's not ridiculous, that's 1/15th, around 7%. Thanks a lot to all.

 

I'm lazy, so I'm beginning with the easiest ones, the optional categories.

For these categories, I think we can analyze things by doing some percentages, since it's one voter one vote.

 

Best group

 

 

Roughly, the H!P group "fandom" is as follows:

Morning Musume。 40%

ANGERME 20%

°C-ute 20%

Kobushi Factory 10%

Country Girls 6%

Juice=Juice 4%

Tsubaki Factory not much, I'm afraid

 

I don't know about you, but I think putting it that way is interesting. Compared what you would think these percentages would be, I think there are confirmations and some surprises:

    1. Obviously MM comes first, yeah, I don't think many people would have believed otherwise. But that's a not a 50%+ majority, that is that more than half of all H!P (H!O) fans are following another group (in priority). I don't know about you, but that wasn't so obvious to me.

    2. ANGERME and °C-ute around the same. And in fact, ANGERME ahead. You can really tell the work on Anju paid off. However, the rivalry between Anju and MM that UF tries to sell isn't materializing here, at least for the moment. Anju and °C combined are still a (tiny little) bit short of MM.

    3. Next we have three smaller groups, Kobushi Factory, Country Girls and Juice=Juice. 10% is impressive for Kobushi. I'm not even sure that order was a no-brainer for everyone. Well, I saw people here being worried about Juice=Juice's lack of steam, and we see it here. Just to give an idea, roughly CG+JJ=KF, and CG+JJ+KF=Anju.

    4. And Tsubaki Factory, with only one vote, not that surprising. They haven't really cemented a fanbase yet. This vote was only a vote for your "best group", and while there may be some people interested in TF, with this vote system, you can't see it

Spoiler

once again, I'm not saying that's a bad voting system, just that its purpose isn't to show fans' interest in groups, but the relative proportions of primary fans of each group.

 

Buono!, KSS and Hokkaidou KSS having somewhat special statuses (and not much votes anyway), I haven't much to say about them.

 

Because I think that's going to be a very long post, and also because it's around 5am where I am, I'm definitely not finishing it right away.

 

[matchan]

Thank you for putting all this together - it was a lot of fun! Happy to see Maachan at the top. I'd like to imagine in her downtime she stumbles across her ranking and sees just how much the int'l community loves her. 

[Gabby]

blah everyone on this blasted site has such bad taste masaki at 1 yall nuts

 

 

Wow look at Momo, lol but lets be honest people only vote for her now because she's on her way out ;P

[IchVermisseDenSommer]

It's after nearly 8am in Germany and I just came home from the club. So I'll keep it short for now:

Thanks a lot all you guys for making this possible again! I love this election and I can only imagine how much work it has to be. You are truely the best!

(Btw there is a little mistake for how much Meimei went down this year compared to last. She wasn't #2 2015 right?)

 

I'm so excited and happy Maa got #1 again and could even manage to get nearly 100 votes more than last year. Same goes for Murotan and Funakki! The fight for Senbatsu, Kami7 and the top 3 was so much harder than last year still my girls made it. I'm a little sad Haachin didn't rank much higher but she won a lot of votes. x333 Go Haachin!!

 

I think overall it gives you a huge advantage when you're a member of MM because usually besides that I think girls that are good on stage are the ones that rank higher than others. The only thing that amazes me every year anew is how low Karin ranks if you look at the poll this way. And omg the Moe hype is real!

 

I checked my spelling three times. I hope I won't wake up tomorrow and die out of embarrasement. Happy New Year everyone!

 

Edit: I imagine Maria, Murotan and Moe will put up a real fight for the top spots next year. Get well soon Maa-chan!!

[miyooooons]

good job meimei ya ended off strong

[leegyep4]

Best Newcomer: Kasahara Momona and Yanagawa Nanami got the same points 15. So Nanami should also receive the 3rd place. 

[Muyim Pimoup]

Maachan still too strong,,

and holy... Moe +50 is what surprised me,, also Muro,Funakki and Maria with fairly big increase,, 

 

i'm sure Kaedi, Reina Momona and TF 2nd gen will also have significant rank increase next year with debut effect,, 

[taskinist]

Oh my god, Akane only gained 5 votes from last year LOL oh well better luck next year

 

Thanks to everybody who helped with this!!!! It's always so fun to see the results, and boy it must be rough compiling everything 

[page11]

Thank you guys for all the hard work !!

Sooo happy that Maachan got #1 for best idol category! I thought she couldn't win this year because she already won last year..

And even #1 for best performer... That's absolutely unexpected as well... just couldn't believe this 

I wish Momochi was in top 10 and Yamaki ranked a little bit higher, though T^T

[aainaa]

Yeah Maachan Congrats!!!

I wish we can tell her how popular she is among international fans..

I keep imagining that she might be depressed right now..

& Kamiko!!! at the top 10.. just 1 year, at number 6!!

Maria & Sakura rank higher  than I expected..

 

So interested to see how the 13th gen will do in 2017 polls.. for some reason I have a feeling both of them might rank higher than most of the 12th gen..

[YellowAccel]

 
I'm a little sad Haachin didn't rank much higher but she won a lot of votes. x333 Go Haachin!!

Yop, she gained 77 points compared to last year and 45 person voted for her. *proudfan*

[Kon-Chan:Itsumademo]

If only I had gotten to vote Kanon would have gotten a higher position Ah well.