Jump to content


Photo

What H!P alternate timeline would you want to visit?


  • Please log in to reply
15 replies to this topic

#1 megumibex

megumibex

    Graduated member

  • Senpai
  • 1165 posts

Posted 03 November 2025 - 06:44 AM

What I mean by this is, if you could visit a universe where any event in H!P history hadn't had happened, or had happened differently, which alternate reality would you most by interested in seeing. 

 

 

Of course, there are many decisions that I wish had been handled differently by management, but the thing that makes me the most curious relates to S/mileage. 

 

 

1. A timeline where they chose different members for the 2nd gen. 

 

I wonder, just how different would the group's life had been if they had chosen, say: Jang Da Yeon, Miyazaki Yuka, Miyamoto Karin, and Aoyagi Momoka instead of the members they actually chose. Would Yuuka still have left? (I imagine so, but we can't know for sure) would the sub-member thing still have happened? (probably, I don't know), would these members have been successful? (JDY= maybe, but it would be a rocky road, MY= probably, MK= definitely, AM= leaning yes, but it's hard to judge). 

 

The ANGERME rebrand wouldn't have happened too, so I wonder if this alternate shadow!s/mileage would still exist today. I'm also still bitter that we never really got to see JDY do anything. So, imagining different versions of s/mileage 2ki's entertains me. 

 

To clarify, this is not me saying I wish 2ki had been different. I'm very happy with the 2ki we got. I just can't help but wonder how things would have gone if either, Kana, Rina, Akari, and Meimi hadn't been there, or if H!P had chosen a different path for them.

 

Do you guys have anything like that? 

 

 

 

 


MM ~ Nonaka Miki, Kaga Kaede ANGERME ~ Sasaki Rikako J=J ~ Takagi Sayuki, Danbara Ruru 

CG ~ Yamaki Risa KF ~ Hamaura Ayano TF~ Kishimoto Yumeno 

KSS - Takase Kurumi, Sato Hikari 

OG ~ Iida Kaori, Suzuki Kanon, Fukuda Kanon, Inaba Manaka, Mitsui Aika, Nakajima Saki

Other Companies ~ Iwase Misaki, Cuca, Nagahama Neru, Maruyama Karin, Khao Kazumaisiri , Suzuka Nakamoto


#2 thegabriel

thegabriel

    Graduated member

  • Senpai
  • 4523 posts

Posted 03 November 2025 - 07:58 AM

The one I always think about is how different MM would be now if 12gen was Miki, Maria, Uta and Kiki.


J=J-段原瑠々 MM.'25-野中美希 

ON-中山夏月姫  BYD-岡村美波

 A-伊勢鈴蘭 RC- 橋田歩果 

TF-河西結心 KSS-大坪茉乃


#3 TheAnna18

TheAnna18

    Yes

  • Senpai
  • 1879 posts

Posted 03 November 2025 - 02:17 PM

A timeline where Mikitty was still in the group during platinum era...

 

If Aibon didn't get kicked out and W continued to release new songs...

 

IF GOTO HANA WAS PUT IN MORNING MUSUME....I'm still not over this lmao

 

or if Tsunku could still sing.....


siggie_zps6431208e.jpg
 


#4 RobianMoon

RobianMoon

    4th gen member

  • Kouhai
  • 242 posts

Posted 03 November 2025 - 02:26 PM

the timeline where iikubo is the leader and use her looks and social ability to be active on tv shows, social media and more radio shows; and her big sister role in momusu where more prominent with the members so they can feel comfortable with each other; i can see a growth on momusu's popularity, ig we just has that chance instead of the socially akward mizuki.

or a timeline where h. rin where suspended instead of oota haruka

#5 kakkowarui

kakkowarui

    5th gen member

  • Kouhai
  • 132 posts

Posted 03 November 2025 - 03:03 PM

I would love to visit a timeline where Country Girls doesn't just fall apart after Momochi graduates. I feel like the group wasn't even given a proper chance to go on without her and I'm still so salty about it. At least they were able to go on for a few more years (even if it was kind of in the background), but I want the timeline where they were able to stay as a proper group. In the same vein, as much as I love Uta in Kyurushite, I'd like to see a timeline where she stays in CG longer.



#6 Ducky Mioda

Ducky Mioda

    5th gen member

  • Kouhai
  • 192 posts

Posted 03 November 2025 - 03:08 PM

a timeline where Perfume + no3b + Momusu all collaborated on Resonant Blue in 2008 and Kanna never left °C-ute back in 2009 (which would mean Maimi, Kanna, Nacky, Airi, Chisato, and Maimai would've been the final lineup) >_>


natlan-dendro-boy.gif

 

​he/they | semiactive | autistic w/ ADHD | southeast Asian | 18+ | anglophilic Genshin-playing weeb | last.fm: @MurotanGekkiLuv | my Genius profile

(推しメン: よこやんパンダさんれいれいえばっきまおぴんるのかおりんごまきさゆみんももちふくちゃんあーりー)


#7 RoseQuartz+Aina

RoseQuartz+Aina

    1st gen member

  • Kouhai
  • 532 posts

Posted 03 November 2025 - 06:24 PM

I would like to see a timeline where Aina Otsuka did not leave Juice=Juice before their major debut, but stayed and evolved within the group.


J10GvsZ.jpeg


#8 Kumi-chan

Kumi-chan

    Aiolia's wife

  • Senpai
  • 1543 posts

Posted 03 November 2025 - 09:19 PM

I need to visit the one in which Aika is not forced to leave the group and can graduate properly later. Then, she would become a soloist for a few years and then she would retire to become a cook. 

 

Also, the one in which TF is still a 6nin members group. 


~Peacefuldays

K-A-T-T-U-N, K-A-T-T-U-N

Yes, we wish mata ashita mo yasashii hi ga noboru you ni~

 


#9 amphibious7

amphibious7

    6th gen member

  • Shinmem
  • 69 posts

Posted 04 November 2025 - 05:29 AM

an alternative timeline where Kobushi Factory received proper support and not ended up like the way it was. 


Posted Image

#10 denadel

denadel

    Sheki-Dol fan

  • Senpai
  • 1161 posts

Posted 07 November 2025 - 09:40 PM

I kinda would wanna see that Iida Kaori was kept as the lead singer instead of being switched out for Abe Natsumi live on TV.


www.hpoldschool.com (under construction)


#11 XFER

XFER

    Graduated member

  • Senpai
  • 1357 posts

Posted 09 November 2025 - 06:59 AM

For me, I would have been delighted if Zukki had never graduated. Like Mizuki and Erina who stayed too long, she could still be in the group, finally as leader. I would love to see her enjoy that position and decide to stay 3 more years after getting leader role. I mean, yes, it sounds insane, but imagine if the two most beautiful girls, both with the most amazing smiles, had cooexisted (I'm talking about Zukki and Yokoyan) the group would be an international smash!


MRkgm6i.png


#12 sukibeam

sukibeam

    Chu-Chi Face

  • Senpai
  • 3223 posts

Posted 11 November 2025 - 05:26 AM

If Aibon didn't get kicked out and W continued to release new songs...
 
or if Tsunku could still sing.....


I long to hear the 3rd unreleased album. Pretty sure the original songs went to other groups, but W was my absolute jam.
And if Tsunku could still sing, omg. He always experimented with such weird things during recording sessions that I feel doesn't happen much anymore. But we probably wouldn't have had all the Takui gems so...

As for my own H!P Twilight Zone?

Kikkawa Yuu properly debuted. H!P was stagnant with new acts at the time, and she certainly wasn't a fit for S/mileage's image nor was Mano becoming the next Matsuura Aya as a solo act. Only place she could have really gone was MM. Imagine a timeline where there was a gen between JunJun/Linlin and the 4 who became 9ki. You would have had Kikkawa there to help wrangle 9ki/10ki with Sayu and Reina, and be leader for a few years after Sayu graduated.

#13 Yossie_Saikou

Yossie_Saikou

    5th gen member

  • Kouhai
  • 177 posts

Posted 11 November 2025 - 09:47 PM

A timeline where GAM (Matsuura Aya and Fujimoto Miki) had more songs/albums and more fame.
They were only active for 2 years (2006-2007) and it's a shame because they were so aesthetically pleasing together.

#14 thegabriel

thegabriel

    Graduated member

  • Senpai
  • 4523 posts

Posted 12 November 2025 - 03:03 AM

I'm going quote myself from the unpopular opinions thread.

The KSS is a gold mine, there shouldn't be any reason why the "flagship" group shouldn't be stacked with the best.

Imagine current MM with Yonemura Kirara, Kitahara Momo, Goto Hana, Kawashima Mifu, and Yofu Runo.

I'm going to go ahead and add Hayashi Niina to the list of Should have been added to MM.


J=J-段原瑠々 MM.'25-野中美希 

ON-中山夏月姫  BYD-岡村美波

 A-伊勢鈴蘭 RC- 橋田歩果 

TF-河西結心 KSS-大坪茉乃


#15 TheAnna18

TheAnna18

    Yes

  • Senpai
  • 1879 posts

Posted 12 November 2025 - 02:27 PM

I long to hear the 3rd unreleased album. Pretty sure the original songs went to other groups, but W was my absolute jam.

You probably already know, but just in case you missed it when it came out, did you know they released a mini album for streaming some years ago with some of the songs from the unreleased album? Choi Waru Devil. 

 

A timeline where GAM (Matsuura Aya and Fujimoto Miki) had more songs/albums and more fame.
They were only active for 2 years (2006-2007) and it's a shame because they were so aesthetically pleasing together.

YES, their voices worked so well together.

 

Kikkawa Yuu properly debuted. 

Okay I want to see this too! I really like some of her solo stuff, but she would have been a good addition to a group too. 


siggie_zps6431208e.jpg
 


#16 miyooooons

miyooooons

    mother

  • Senpai
  • 2134 posts

Posted 14 November 2025 - 11:24 AM

I've gotten hate for this but

Kobushi adding a 2nd gen in mid-2018, and it being Noguchi Kurumi & Horie Kizuki, both KSS I think deserved to debut & would've rounded out the lineup well and were in their age range (1998-2001).

MM:  A: 

J=J:  TF: 

BY: 

ON:  RC: ⬤⬤⬤⬤⬤⬤⬤⬤⬤

ALUM: Meimi Maasa ~ edited: 2025/11/15





1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users

× Upcoming Releases