What does being a rising star in the acting world have to do with singing? It's obvious that when I said "talent", I wasn't talking about her acting. We're here to talk about MUSIC. And face it, she's not an amazing singer. Yeah, she can hold a melody, but the other girl? She's great.
And I don't think you understand the meaning of critical. If I said something like, "That girl needs to kill herself because she sucks."--THAT would be critical. But I actually think they have potential as singers. They've come this far anyways, right? Why not push themselves to be the best they can be?
Talent doesn't mean just singing. It doesn't magically become the same as another word just because this is a music themed forum. And don't put words in my mouth either. I never said ANYTHING about her singing abilities. I'm just defending her cause you said she had no talent.
By critical, I mean you just come off as being rude. You pretty much just sarcastically went, "They have talent. Oh just kidding, only one girl has talent and the rest have none." I think you need to choose your words more carefully cause it just sounds like you find a reason to diss them every time.
I want to learn the dance
