412 replies to this topic

[keaine]

^x2 it's not ranks 87-43 anymore

[Chibs]

Victory!!!

[core2quad]

^x2 it's not ranks 87-43 anymore

87-43 was posted in previous page yesterday

[thegabriel]

Thank You for your hard work.

Let's see how my list did....

Best Idol

12 +10 Fukumura Mizuki

42 +9   Miyazaki Yuka

27 +8   Yamaki Risa

 5  +7   Ishida Ayumi

 2  +6   Oda Sakura

23 +5   Ogata Haruna

 1  +4   Sato Masaki

 7  +3   Murota Mizuki

19 +2   Kanazawa Tomoko

24 +1   Uemura Akari

 

Best Idol Group - Morning Musume '17

Best Newcomer - Danbara Ruru

Best Singer - Takagi Sayuki -3rd

Best Dancer - Ishida Ayumi -2nd

Idol you want to push - Yanagawa Nanami -6th

Not Bad!

[minaeshi]

 

^x2 it's not ranks 87-43 anymore

87-43 was posted in previous page yesterday

 

he was just telling me to edit the title of the new list  

[LiamMusume]

Best Idol
+10 Wada Ayaka 16
+9 Ogata Risa 43
+8 Nomura Minami 49
+7 Asakura Kiki 37
+6 Akiyama Mao 45
+5 Iikubo Haruna 14
+4 Miyamoto Karin 21
+3 Hagiwara Mai 40
+2 Yonemura Kirara 73
+1 Kanatsu Mizuki 68

Categories
Best Idol Group - ANGERME
Best Newcomer - Kawamura Ayano
Best Singer - Akiyama Mao      I really don't remember why I voted for her in this category, she isn't the best but she definitely impressed me this year.
Best Dancer - Inaba Manaka
Idol you want to push - Ogata Risa

 

Fairly bad 

[celestia414]

Maachan cannot be beaten in this election. She really is the Sasshi of h!p. She's won the poll by Japanese fans the last couple of years too.

 

Happy and surprised by how high Yokoyan ranked, also how much Yanamin has gone up.

[core2quad]

@minaeshi My misunderstanding   


 

Best Idol
+10 Sato Masaki 1
+9 Suzuki Airi 10
+8 Murota Mizuki 7
+7 Okai Chisato 26
+6 Nonaka Miki 3
+5 Morito Chisaki 11
+4 Yokoyama Reina 4
+3 Fukumura Mizuki 12
+2 Ogata Risa 43
+1 Yamaki Risa 27

Best Idol Group - ℃-ute 4
Best Newcomer - Yokoyama Reina 2
Best Singer - Oda Sakura
Best Dancer - Inaba Manaka
Idol you want to push - Nonaka Miki 2

FINAL VOTE

not too bad 

[mizukingdom1]

Best Idol

+10 Fukumura Mizuki (12th down since last year)

+9 Inaba Manaka (34th still good despite not being there for half a year)

+8 Kamikokuryo Moe (9th still in top ten)

+7 Murota Muzuki (7th also in top ten)

+6 Sato Masaki (1st of course it's Maa-chan)

+5 Yokoyama Reina (4th I'm so shocked and happy for her) sorry for the yellow

+4 Uemura Akari (24th one better than last year so that's something)

+3 Akiyama Mao (45th in the middle of all the Tsubaki members so that's ok)

+2 Hirose Ayaka (39th poor Kobushi is all I can say)

+1 Oda Sakura (2nd woo go Sakura, I wonder if she can close the gap between her and Maa-chan next year)

 

Categories

Best Idol Group - Angerme (3rd of course they can't beat MM, but also well done J=J)

Best Newcomer - Danbara Ruru (1st yay, also very happy for Yokoyan)

Best Singer - Fukumura Mizuki (8th? didn't expect her to win but she is one of the most stable singers)

Best Dancer - Inaba Manaka (1st she is the queen of dance)

Idol you want to push - Akiyama Mao (rank? want to see more of her in the future)

 

Final vote

Not bad

[Fall]

The spreadsheet is really interesting to process, particularly with some of the meteoric rises compared to past results.  Miki's rebound was another point of interest considering her slight dip last year.  Half of the voting users giving points to Maa-chan makes her seem like one of the most universally liked members in years.  Funaki's high rating last year wasn't just a fluke and, theoretically, is presently as popular as Fukumura with more people voting for her for the same amount of points.

 

My top 3 were spot on.

 

Spoiler

 

Best Idol

+10 Sato Masaki (1)

+9 Oda Sakura (2)

+8 Nonaka Miki (3)

+7 Inoue Rei (20)

+6 Funaki Musubu (12)

+5 Murota Mizuki (7)

+4 Yamazaki Yuhane (57)

+3 Ogawa Rena (62)

+2 Ichioka Reina (60)

+1 Taguchi Natsumi (50)

 

Categories

Best Idol Group - Morning Musume '17 (1)

Best Newcomer - Danbara Ruru (1)

Best Singer - Takagi Sayuki (3)

Best Dancer - Murota Mizuki (4)

Idol you want to push - Yonemura Kirara (Well, at least one other person voted for her lol)

 

FINAL VOTE

 

[core2quad]

@mizukingdom1
Angerme is 2nd in Best Idol Group, ℃-ute is 3rd
Akiyama Mao is 24th in Idol you want to push if I count it correctly

Edited by core2quad, 01 January 2018 - 04:06 AM.

[keaine]

^ nope, in the 2017 poll, Angerme is 3rd and °C-ute is 4th, whereas Juice=Juice takes the 2nd spot

[core2quad]

^ oh, my mistake
thanks

[keaine]

https://matsuri.5ch..../1514779441/l50

 

here's the usual japanese discussion about the results

 

(to be honest, I always have fun reading these)

[core2quad]

^ lol, I am glad to know that they are interested in discussing our results

[IchVermisseDenSommer]

What do they say??
This was a really good election. I'm a little sad for Anjus most popular members downfall. They need good releases next year. Besides that I'm so excited to see how Miki vs. Yokoyan will play out next year!

[keaine]

Well the discussion is still ongoing, and there are too much messages going different ways but anyway, the main topics are:

- how high Yokoyan is, and trying to explain it (her smile, like Zukki n°2), and conversely, how low Kaedii is (while she's 6th on the Japanese poll)

- the group poll, and how the evolution from 2016 to 2017 has been... well, kind of expected; in particular, they insist on Juice=Juice's rise and coming 2nd, concluding (rightly so I think) that the World Tour has been successful, as well as Angerme losing steam

- Karin's ranking which is still low for them (she's like 4th on the Japanse poll), even though she's up from last year

- how Danbara and Yanamin are the top ranking members from Juice=Juice,

 

The rest is: trying to understand the poll and the different categories, saying "foreigners have a good sense" or reversely "foreigners have a bad sense".

 

oh, and of course, the domination of Maachan.

[IchVermisseDenSommer]

^

Thanks a lot! I'm really so thankful for all your work. I just came home from the party and will soon go to bed. So I will thank you guys properly tomorrow. 

I really hope Henkka will again translate the best posts of this discussion. After all one of the main reasons why this poll is so much fun every year is because we can be sure that the Japanese wot will pay attention to the foreign fandom once a year.

And I just love how hurt they are by Karins ranking each year. I love her but at the same time I hope her rank will decrease again next year. Just for the wota comments. (not really but...you know... if it would happen then there's nothing we could do right? lol) 

[Obsidian]

Thanks for all the hard work guys! Also I think polls like this will serve an important purpose when they get back to the agency which I suspect they do given the 5ch thread etc. They should be very very happy with the results for Ju=Ju. They rightfully identified them as the most capable of taking over C-ute's torch and maybe even running a bit further with it. I however think that any H!P group would still do well and get a really positive reaction doing overseas concerts, nothing beats the live experience and meeting the Idols in the flesh. *rambling* the main point is hopefully it means they'll be even more H!P overseas concerts this year.

 

For Danbara, yes she ranked high and was a high gainer but not that much, she was just already amazingly popular even as a trainee. That'll only increase with more Ju=Ju overseas concerts because she's a 'god level' performer.