64 replies to this topic

[Muyim Pimoup]

 

Uta-chan 

 

^ that i'm fully agree too,, 

[KumaixKamei]

Oda Sakura

 

Singing: 9/10

Dancing: 8/10

Looks: 9/10

 

Yet there are a lot of girls I see as perfect Idols: Kanatomo, Uta, Airi.

 

For me a good Idol is someone that is amazing in a group, but also alone in a lot of diffrent ways!

[megumibex]

Ok I think I have this figured out, best all rounder in singing, dancing and looks for me would be Tanaka Reina and Suzuki Airi. However tbh I don't think those traits necessarily make someone a good idol (nothing against the girls I mentioned, they are great idols). What makes a good idol is them being interesting to watch but that is really subjective and unquantifiable. For me though the perfect idol would be either Momoko or Sayumi as well as Reina and Airi. Momo and Sayu are both so unbelievably dedidcated to everything involved in being an idol that it makes up for their weaknesses.

[cjkuma]

I'd say Reina, Momochi, and Airi? When I think "perfect idol", those three pop into my head.

[taylorniw]

Airi if she was better at variety. It's pretty much all she's missing.

[JennyInTokyo]

I'd have to say the perfect idols for me would be Airi Suzuki and Takahashi Ai! Their personalities is something to work on because they are both sweet girls with a shy personality but they had moments where they could be dorky which is what I wish I could see more of. So here is my ranking for both of them:

 

AIRI
Singing: 8.5
Dancing: 8
Personality: 6

AI
Singing: 8.5
Dancing: 9

Personality: 6

 

It is all just my honest opinion by the way

[SunnyBunny]

When I think of the perfect idol Sayumi is the first member that pops into my head tbh. Also Maeda Yuuka was pretty perfect in S/mileage imo

[cha]

Matsuura Aya rules  

[CloudStrife4Ril]

When I think of the perfect idol Sayumi is the first member that pops into my head tbh. Also Maeda Yuuka was pretty perfect in S/mileage imo

I 100% agree with this. Sayumi and Yuukarin are pretty much my Idol obession during the time they are still in H!P. Looks wise, these two are hard to beat back then IMO.

[SaraSaki]

In all H!P I think it's Reina. She's just perfect at everything that she does.

But at the current lineup the "perfect idol" title is between Airi and Momo.
They have the looks, they can sing and dance, have a personality, ect..

[Driftingthroughtheskies]

Current H!P, I'd say Momochi and Airi.  Maybe I'm just biased though.

[randomrrr]

This thread is supposed to be bias

Because there's "in your opinion" in the title.

[Kinjiru]

Sayumi was perfect in that she had the looks, a true love for her own group, variety skills and an integrity and devotion to the concept of idol that we should be seeing much more of. And that's just the tip of the iceberg. Yes, she might have not been the best performer, but that is not necessary for an idol and I'd say actually contributes to it since there is always room to improve and makes the fans want to cheer her on. In a way, having flaws is even better. She easily beats out Matsuura or any other previous H!P talent when it comes to being an idol.

 

I can't think of anyone that rivals Sayu in current H!P, Momochi is definitely up there but she is too much of a professional to be perfect, as ironic as it sounds. All other examples are flawed in some ways.

[randomrrr]

^

Since I don't know what a perfect idol should be, I limit it to looks, singing and dancing.

Just goes to show how little I know...

[taskinist]

Of current members, I think Murotan is headed there.

 

Singing: 8.5/10

Dancing: 8/10 (???)

Looks: 8/10

[Ares13]

hmm ...

So for singing .. is hitting the high notes and vocal clarity more important or bringing out the feeling of the song more important ..
For dancing .. having sharp and clean movement and excellent feel of the music more important or bring the flavor of the music and capturing you attention with her movement more important?
For personality .. which is the best .. does being loud and outspoken and lighting up the situation got more personality or being quiet, but giving out an pleasure, nice, peaceful characteristic has more personality ..
for look .. oh come on .. that's totally base on personal taste ..

For me .. base on my period when I am a H!P fan from 2007 ..
I hate to say it .. It is Momochi .. even though I don't like her at all ..

To me she started low ..work her way up to the front ..
She has reasonable talent and is good in both singing and dancing ..
She has the ability to light up the situation when require ..
she stayed around really long .. she was able to handle both being an idol and studies really well ..
and was able to change herself the right way when it is needed ..from being a member to a playing manager ..

[callirae]

Sato Masaki

 

Personality - 10000/10

Singing - 8/10

Looks - 9/10

Funaki Musubu has the potential to become the ideal idol with time, I think.

[Jenksy]

Reina's definately the perfect idol. But going for the current groups... It would be Fukumura Mizuki for me!

[Corpenicus62]

Of the current lineup, I would say Suzuki Airi, Karin, and Murotan.

 

Two up-and comers -- Funaki and Kamiko.

[miyooooons]

Tamura Meimi, Hands down.

 

*siiiigh*