47 replies to this topic

[the rose garden]

TBH most of H!P's lyrics are not suitable for (pre)teens :')

 

I mean we had 13-year old Fukuda Asuka singing about the morning after

[AngelAndz]

TBH most of H!P's lyrics are not suitable for (pre)teens :')
 
I mean we had 13-year old Fukuda Asuka singing about the morning after

I was honestly surprised when I found out that Asuka was only 12 when Morning Musume formed, so I wonder if the excuse was that she didn't look her age. With Momohime you can clearly see that she's a little girl, so I think it would be weird seeing her performing some of the more grown up Momusu songs. And by that I don't mean Tsumetai because that's the only Momusu song with a more grown up them that can be sung by the younger girls in Hello!Project because the meaning of the song can be admitted to suit any age

[Lurkette]

Yes, because little girls are

 

not

 

 

allowed

 

 

in

 

 

Morning

 

 

Musume

 

 

Oh wait.

 

Seriously. Age doesn't matter. Appearance of age doesn't matter. They will pick who they want to pick, and that may very well include Momohime (that's a terrible picture of her though) or Kirara. I'm sure no one would have assumed Haga would "fit" into the group, but there she is, same as all the other infants who made it. A lot of people have made this argument about several different groups, but it never holds true. Young ones will always have a place in idol groups. 

[AngelAndz]

^
I'm not saying she doesn't have a place, I just see her fitting in more with Country Girls, especially given that her oshi is Momochi

Even if she does join Momusu I'd put her in for 14th or 15th gen more than 13th gen. Yes, I am very aware of all the girls who joined aged 12, but to me at least none of them looked as young as Momohime looks right now. If I didn't already know that she's 12 years old I would've thought she was only 8 or 9 years. This is what I meant when I said that she looks like a little girl and that would look weird. I know it's a lame excuse and I think that if she joined that several of the girls would pretty much want to mother her, but I honestly don't think she'll join just yet if she does end up joining Momusu *hopes that all made sense*

btw, I was wondering if some of the KSS who aren't taking part in the Hello!Project Summer tour are taking part in the KSS version of the 13ki auditions?

I was looking at the photo of everyone performing the opening number in the first concert and girls like Takase and Mizukichi (Kanatsu Mizuki) who usually take part in Hello!Project concert tours and concerts aren't in the photo and trust me even with my crappy eyesight at the moment I looked properly and doubled checked to make sure. If there are any KSS missing from the tour taking part in the 13ki auditions including Takase and Mizukichi I wish them well

[ShiningLight445]

 

TBH most of H!P's lyrics are not suitable for (pre)teens :')
 
I mean we had 13-year old Fukuda Asuka singing about the morning after

I was honestly surprised when I found out that Asuka was only 12 when Morning Musume formed, so I wonder if the excuse was that she didn't look her age. With Momohime you can clearly see that she's a little girl, so I think it would be weird seeing her performing some of the more grown up Momusu songs. And by that I don't mean Tsumetai because that's the only Momusu song with a more grown up them that can be sung by the younger girls in Hello!Project because the meaning of the song can be admitted to suit any age

 

 

I read this and thought of young 12 year old Riho performing Moonlight Night with Ai and Risa

 

 

But for KSS it doesn't really matter to me. I would be happy with anyone And it would be really great if it were a girl who has been in KSS for awhile.

Just a thought: If H!P really wanted more KSS in Momusu, they should just hold a KSS-only audition instead of opening the audition for all of Japan and then decide on half KSS in the next generation.

For example: If they have a 3 member 13th generation and two are KSS.

[celestia414]

Not necessarily who I want, but my guess is Kokoro. She has a unique look where some people would think she's pretty and some would think she's ugly and they like adding girls like that to MM. She also seems to be getting a lot of attention lately and her performance skills aren't bad.

[Da-manta-ray]

I've seen this argument around a few times, but why does having an oshimen in a certain group mean that they are more suited for that group? o.O

[TANTAIZI]

For my point,None of them is suitable for Momusu 13gen,

The reason maybe is quite obvious,the 13th gen audition of MM is looking for some real ace members(good appearance with pretty strong singing-skill or dancing-skill or any kind bonus-skill that mixed together is a much more preference).