1795 replies to this topic

[Himalia™]

Post 867 has new details for this game restarting. The basics are you can vote for anybody you wish including yourself but only one person per catagory.

Voteing ends on the 31st of August.


You can vote for all members of HP past or present.
All groups or sub groups of HP past or present.
Any generation of Morning Musume
M-Line
Hello Project as a whole (This is not specfic to a person or group but fandom in general)
Any group or artist that is clearly related to HP. Such as Hangry and Angry

All votes to be sent via PM


Banners for the latest game provide by CharloKylie
















This thread is just purely for the title of " Greatest fan"

It should be treated as no more than just a bit of fun

A somewhat subjective title to say the least.


There are many catogories as well.

For example ......

Greatest HP fan
Greatest Morning Musume fan
Greatest C-ute fan
Greatest Ai Takahashi fan
Greatest Risako Sugaya fan
Greatest Maki Goto fan
Greatest Rika Ishii fan (There has to be one surely )
Greatest 6th Gen fan (would seem odd to have a greatest 3rd or 7th Gen fan award as well as a greatest Maki Goto and Koharu Kusumi fan )

Just think of the class you want to vote for and pm it to me with who you think that person is.
It can apply to both past and present members.
No reason why some people could even be more than one of them.


Anyway there will be a prize for this , any person who wins their class will be given a unique member group title on this forum. Kind ok like the Senpai group name you could say. Could be as simple as C-ute fanboy/fangirl etc anything like that within reason. This again is just a suggestion and could easily be changed.

So all you have to do is vote via pm.
You can vote for as many different people as you want but not more than 5 people per class.
You should send them to me in order of who you think is ranked highest as such.
You do not have to state a reason but it helps since it counts for more that way.
You can vote for as many classes as you wish for example you could vote for someone for every member of Morning Musume plus the group as a whole.

Please consider why you are voting for someone dont just vote your friends for the sake of it unless you really belive that to be correct

Some example below could apply and are by no means limited to.

Seen them live
Collects there stuff
Translates stuff
Contributes in some way because of their fandom
Don't overlook the small things often these can add upto more than one big thing.
There are so many different factors involved so the above is just a small example.

Also keep in mind just because someone collects stuff and has more than someone else it does not mean they are a bigger fan it means they have more stuff so is by no means a win all, the same should apply to all financial aspects. Yes it is a factor but not everything. Aplly common sense, i guess selling a kidney to see them does count for alot though


Also keep in mind negative stuff as well the person at the top of the pile should really not have any negative stuff associated with them at all.

This is fundamentally for fun and partially because i am curious to see who gets voted for

[matt9210]

So do we pick from the categories listed, or just send a vote for any member? E.g. I think _____ is *any H!P member's name* biggest fan.

I ask because you said 'For example......', but because of the amount of H!P members, it'd result in a lot of categories if they're not chosen by you

[Himalia™]

Within reason anything you can think of.

Below are some more examples.


Any group past or present

Any specfic gen

Any specfic member of any group past or present

Any solo artist past or present.

Yes that is alot of catagories. So perhaps i should add a certain number would have to be reached for anybody to be considered. For example 1 person gets 1 vote for Ultimate Tsunku fan i guess they are not that Ultimate with just one vote even if nobody else gets a single vote

You dont have to do all your votes straight away perhaps you can only think or some its ok to send some more a few days later. Also no need to vote for everything for some its likely that you might have no idea.

So consider carefully when voting don't just vote someone for the sake of it only if they stand out to you, perhaps you think there is only 1 for a certain class. Thats ok just vote for that one if thats the case.

Some classes are more likely to get many votes compared to others.

[KuteKim]

I love this idea.
Do we just come up with any category we want?

[Risa/Misa]

Yeah like pairings? I am curious. >3

[liamers]

I sent in my [many] votes

[°Chrisron]

Nice idea, but wow, that will be a lot of categories. Who will win the Sheki-Dol category, and who's Chinatsu Miyoshi's greatest fan? And are for instance Mini Moni and Shin Mini Moni different groups?

I will definetly not get any votes, since I'm not the greatest fan of anything, but I will definetly vote for others. (After I've decided who deserves my votes)



More questions:

1. Is it possible to vote for you, Himalia? (Not saying that I will, but I'd like to know if it's an option)
2. What happens if a person is voted the biggest fan in more than one category?

EDIT: Yes, I think it would be a good idea with a certain number of votes reached so nobody becomes greatest fan with just one vote.

[Azu-Nyan]

I'm gonna wait for Himalia to answer KuteKim's question to if we can do any category we want, 'cause I really wanna do this.

[nono:)bbz]

Sent in my nominees. It'll be cool to see who most people on here consider to be the greatest fan of a certain girl / group / generation.

[KuteKim]

This will definitely be fun, although I don't expect myself to win anything..
I'm going to wait with Azu-chin.

[matt9210]

Sent in my nominees too

[SweetHoney]

Oh I gotta send in mine~~ ♥

Ahaha I wonder if anyone will nomiate me for greatest sayu fan

[Azu-Nyan]

^
To be honest, I actually was going to nominate you...

[KuteKim]

I want to nominate.

[SweetHoney]

@Azu Ahaha you should of :x

Alright going to send in mine soon Mr. H~! ^^

[ErikaUmedaFan]

Ah this is a good idea!~ I want to participate too! i gotta think!

[Himalia™]

I love this idea.
Do we just come up with any category we want?

Within reason yes.

Yeah like pairings? I am curious. >3

I guess that would be ok, what did you have in mind ?

Nice idea, but wow, that will be a lot of categories. Who will win the Sheki-Dol category, and who's Chinatsu Miyoshi's greatest fan? And are for instance Mini Moni and Shin Mini Moni different groups?

I guess Mini Moni and Shin-Mini Moni should count as seperate but there is no reason why the same person could not win both.

1. Is it possible to vote for you, Himalia? (Not saying that I will, but I'd like to know if it's an option)
2. What happens if a person is voted the biggest fan in more than one category?

1. Yes you can but damn i have some arguments against myself in the negative context.
2. No reason why not. Some could well end up being the winner for more than one class.

EDIT: Yes, I think it would be a good idea with a certain number of votes reached so nobody becomes greatest fan with just one vote.

Thanks for the feedback on that how do other feel on this ?





Some questions i have also been asked.


Does cosplay count towards being the greatest fan ?

Yes i cant see why it does not count. Every little helps and it applies to boys and girls Its just girls "tend" to be better at it


Does making unofficial HP merchandise count ?

Yes to a degree it does but i personally would say it does not if its purely for profit.

Some people would go to events etc if they could , does this count ?

To a degree yes. Yes i am sure just about every one of us would like to go to every event. So in that respect it should count for very little. I would be looking more at the ones who had to go to extrems to go. Sell kidney saved for 3 years to be able to etc.

I have also been asked do torrent uploaders count ?

Yes i think its contributing because it allows other to see whats available and some FC stuff is so hard to get if your not a member this is the only way it can be done. So yes to a degree this counts as well.



Can i change my mind once i have voted ?

Yes if you change your mind about who you voted for simply send me a pm with new nominees

[Himalia™]

One major thing i will add is yes it is ok to post reasons why you think someone specfic should be considered or simply just your own personal views on what could count since this could easily lead to people considering things they perhaps would not of originally.

Plus some may not know certain things about certain people therefor might never nominate them.

For example °Chrisron has the worldest largest collection of Tsunku cosplay

[matt9210]

I also like the idea about people should get a minimum number of votes to win I don't know what the minimum could be though.

[Himalia™]

I was thinking a reasonable amount like 10. Not so high but not really low either. I will consider this carefully.